Those Commies are still out there you know . . .

The way Jesus wanted it

This is last week’s story and we political junkies know all about it: Congress voted 361-9 to re-affirm that the motto of the United States is still In God We Trust. But did you know that our ever-vigilant congress critters took time to do it five years ago too? I guess we can’t be too careful. This time, they had a thoughtful debate, but we may assume that this is the sentiment that carried the day:

“Is God God? Or is man God? In God do we trust, or in man do we trust?” said Rep. Trent Franks (R-Ariz.). He was laying out the deeper meaning behind this debate — saying it was a chance for the House to reassert that it believes there is divine goodness and order in the universe.

If there isn’t, Franks said, “we should just let anarchy prevail because, after all, we are just worm food. So indeed we have the time to reaffirm that God is God and in God do we trust.”

I was in school when the beautiful motto of this nation was tossed aside for a cheap political point. E Pluribus Unum –  Out of Many, One. Probably the finest most aspirational motto of any state in history.

But there were Commies out there in the ’50’s and they were – gasp! – godless! And atom bombs would not be enough to protect us; only a deity could do that. So we shielded ourselves with a completely unoriginal, generic motto, one that would make any theocracy proud: In God We Trust. Which means exactly nothing.

That wasn’t enough of course, because maybe Uncle Joe Stalin wouldn’t bother to read our motto. So to be really really safe, we added a little protection into the Pledge of Allegiance as well.

One nation, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all would no longer do. To assure full-fledged homeland security, it had to be One nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. (God’s justice or man’s?)

I never say it. I like the old one.

5 responses to “Those Commies are still out there you know . . .

  1. Quite why “E pluribus unum” was chosen is not clear. It occurs first in Vergil, but not the great epic of the Aeneid with its fall of Troy and promise of Rome, but another quieter work on cooking and a receipt on the making of salad oil. “From many one”. Curious really and rather comforting that the Founders found time to read cook books.


    • 🙂 🙂 The cook book part is new to me!

      Actually David, I think it’s perfectly fit to a nation of immigrants – the idea that we would draw from all over the world, but then become one nation. From the very beginning the founders knew we’d be dependant on immigration for growth, something they dearly wanted (maybe not Jefferson).

      So yeah, I think it’s pretty perfect.


  2. Immigrants have been coming from all over since the day the Pilgrims arrived in 1620. We or our ancestors literally stole the land from the many different Indian tribes, and you what that turned into…bloodshed, stealing, promises broken. Where was god almighty when all this was going on.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s